Steinbeck, John "Cannery Row" - 1945
For the Classics Spin #38, we received #17 and this was my novel.
I have read several John Steinbeck novels and loved them all. With this one, I was expecting something along the line of "The Grapes of Wrath", some story about the people who lived during the Great Depression and how they managed. Instead, I read about a group of unruly people whom I couldn't care for.I'm sure you have read novels where your thoughts did not stay with the plot. Where you had to go back and read whole paragraphs over and over again. I had this with this story, well, I wouldn't even call it a story. It was an amalgamation of characters who couldn't bring together one decent idea.
I have heard several times that this is a funny novel. I cannot agree with that. I didn't see any humour in it. Sorry.
From the back cover:
"Unburdened by the material necessities of the more fortunate, the denizens of Cannery Row discover rewards unknown in more traditional society. Henri the painter sorts through junk lots for pieces of wood to incorporate into the boat he is building, while the girls from Dora Flood’s bordello venture out now and then to enjoy a bit of sunshine. Lee Chong stocks his grocery with almost anything a man could want, and Doc, a young marine biologist who ministers to sick puppies and unhappy souls, unexpectedly finds true love. Cannery Row is just a few blocks long, but the story it harbors is suffused with warmth, understanding, and a great fund of human values. First published in 1945, Cannery Row focuses on the acceptance of life as it is - both the exuberance of community and the loneliness of the individual. John Steinbeck draws on his memories of the real inhabitants of Monterey, California, and interweaves their stories in this world where only the fittest survive - creating what is at once one of his most humorous and poignant works. In Cannery Row, John Steinbeck returns to the setting of Tortilla Flat to create another evocative portrait of life as it is lived by those who unabashedly put the highest value on the intangibles - human warmth, camaraderie, and love."
I contribute to this page: Read the Nobels and you can find all my blogs about Nobel Prize winning authors and their books here.
I haven't read this one, but I've always heard it was funny, too. Sorry that didn't end up being true. Have you read Tortilla Flat? I'm curious if you have, if you liked it better.
ReplyDeleteI have read a few books where others claim it was funny but I couldn't agree, Cold Comfort Farm, I Capture the Castle, all classics. Don't know what's wrong with me. ;)
DeleteAnyway, no, I have not read Tortilla Flat and since that's a sequel to this one, I doubt I ever will. Have you read it?
I have a huge book with his collected works. I just have to start reading it one day. I have only read Of Mice and Men, which I loved.
ReplyDeleteOh yes, I loved Of Mice and Men, as well, Lisbeth. As I did East of Eden, The Grapes of Wrath, The Pearl, anything by him. Until I read this one. Hope you will like it.
DeleteSorry you were disappointed with this one Marianne. It's on my TBR, so I will apporach with caution when I get to it.
ReplyDeleteB24 and his GF were in California for Christmas last year, and knowing that both myself and Mr Books were Steinbeck fans, they went to Cannery Row and took some pics for us :-)
I suppose there are people who enjoy it, Brona. I usually like John Steinbeck. Just not this one.
DeleteIsn't it nice when the youngsters think about us when on hoilday? I always love that.
Oh and thank you for reminding me about the Read the Nobels website. I have also contributed to it over the years, but had forgotten about since my move to WP.
ReplyDeleteI think you belong to those people whom I met via the Notbel page, Brona. Unfortunately, we can't get a hold of Aloi who is running the page and there are some things that don't work well. I hope we will be able to get in touch with her soon.
Delete"I'm sure you have read novels where your thoughts did not stay with the plot. Where you had to go back and read whole paragraphs over and over again. I had this with this story, well, I wouldn't even call it a story. It was an amalgamation of characters who couldn't bring together one decent idea." This could have been written about Tortilla Flats too. It isn't just racism that damns some older books. Sometimes, they just can't make the leap to the expectations and experience of modern readers.
ReplyDeleteI doubt I will approach Tortilla Flats, as it is a sequel. If I don't enjoy the first novel, I probably won't like the second one, etiher. So, I guess we have the same opinion about both books, Lisa.
DeleteI've not read this Steinbeck. A few years ago I struggled through East of Eden. It took me nearly a year, but I did finish it. I think that will do it for me.
ReplyDeleteMy CC Spin book was A Bell for Adano by Hersey, which I liked a lot. I'd be honored if you'd take a peek at my review: A Bell for Adano
Thanks, Anne. I suppose Steinbeck is not for you. We don't all have to like the same authors, so don't worry. I really liked East of Eden, this is the first Steinbeck that wasn't for me.
DeleteThanks for mentioning your Spin, I will visit your post with pleasure, always nice to see what others are reading.